Thinking about starting a newsletter for your agency? I get it, especially if referrals have carried you for years and you’d like one channel that’s yours. I run one myself, the Dynamic Agency Dispatch, and I’d tell most agency owners to have one eventually. The catch is in the word eventually.
A newsletter is worth it for an agency once something you already run is sending people to it. Nobody on your list can see anybody else on it, so the list doesn’t grow on its own, and it grows exactly as fast as whatever feeds it.
This is for the owner of a small agency, roughly 3 to 15 people, who’s deciding whether to start a list now and wants to know what it’ll cost and what it can’t do.
Why a newsletter can’t find new subscribers on its own
A newsletter can’t find new subscribers on its own because every issue lands in one inbox at a time, and none of your subscribers ever sees who else is reading. The way I put it in the Attention Play Library, our guide to 31 ways of getting in front of agency buyers: “Your own list is a waiting room. Your subscribers can’t see each other, so it doesn’t build on its own and every name has to be walked in from somewhere else.”
That’s the mechanic, and it’s worth sitting with before you set anything up. A LinkedIn post can travel because the people who see it can see each other reacting to it. A newsletter issue can be the best thing you’ve ever written and it still reaches exactly the people who were already on the list the morning you hit send. Forwards happen, but you can’t plan a quarter around them.
So the useful question is who’s going to walk the names in.
What a newsletter costs an agency
A newsletter costs an agency about 2 to 3 hours a week, every week, with no end date. That’s the number I’d plan around for one send a week or one a fortnight, and the rhythm matters more than the length.
The harder cost is the wait. Expect it to feel pointless for six months and to be your best asset in three years. Those six months are where a lot of agency newsletters stop (and I understand why), because nothing on the calendar tells you it’s working. Open rates won’t, and the replies tend to come from peers more than buyers.
If you want a broader feel for how long different channels take to show anything, I wrote up honest timelines for each one. A newsletter belongs at the slow end, because it compounds, and compounding looks like nothing for a while.
What a newsletter does well once it’s fed
Once people are arriving from somewhere else, a newsletter does two things nothing else in your marketing does. It’s the one room you own, where you set the rules and nobody can change the algorithm on you, and it appreciates over time while most other channels reset every time you stop posting. It also survives the things that wreck other channels: a platform change, a community going quiet, a conference getting cancelled.
The other thing it does is hold people while they get to know you. When I ask a new client how they heard about me and walk the path backward, it often runs the same way: a podcast I guested on, then my LinkedIn for a while, and sometimes the newsletter after that. They found me somewhere else, and for the ones who joined, the newsletter was where they kept hearing from me until they were ready to talk. That’s the job the Dynamic Agency Dispatch does for me, and I’d call it a demonstration of the mechanics rather than proof: it’s where people land after they’ve met me somewhere else. That’s a big part of what I mean by time on brand, the minutes someone spends with your thinking before they ever book a call.
When a newsletter is worth it: name what feeds it
Before you start a newsletter, name the thing you’re already doing that will send people to it, and roughly how often it puts you in front of someone new. If you can’t name one, your next move is the feeder.
A feeder is anything that puts you in front of people who don’t know you yet and gives them a reason to want more. Being a guest on somebody else’s show works. So does a co-hosted session on somebody else’s list, where the owner carries you in and their audience gets something useful. A scorecard or self-diagnostic that a buyer can run on their own agency works well too, because it hands people a reason to stay in touch that has nothing to do with you pitching.
Try this self-test this week. Look at the last month and count the times you were in front of someone who’d never heard of you. If that number is close to zero, a newsletter will be you writing to the same handful of people every Thursday. If it’s steady, a newsletter is how you stop losing those people after the first touch.
Four things that kill an agency newsletter
Four things kill an agency newsletter, and the first one decides most of the others.
No feeder. Starting it before you have anywhere to send people from is the test above. Without a feeder the list stays flat, the owner reads that as “newsletters don’t work for us,” and the whole idea gets shelved.
Irregular sends. Publishing whenever you feel like it trains people to stop opening. Pick weekly or fortnightly and keep it, even when the issue is shorter than you’d like.
Writing for peers. It’s tempting to write to other agency owners and marketers because they’re the ones who reply, and they’re rarely the ones who hire you. Write to one buyer, the person with the problem you solve, and accept that they’ll reply less.
Announcements. A list used as an announcement channel for your own news (new hire, new logo, new service page) gives nobody a reason to open it, because nobody signed up for that. Make the subscribe offer a specific thing they want, and keep every issue about their problem.
The Attention Play Library adds one hard rule on top of those four: if the thing you started and abandoned before was a newsletter, the answer to starting another one is no.
Should a newsletter be your first lead gen channel?
A newsletter shouldn’t be an agency’s first lead gen channel, and it’s worth being honest with yourself about why the idea is appealing. A newsletter feels like control, and control is what an agency living on referrals is short of. But the control only shows up after the list is being fed, so if referrals are still your only source of new conversations, the first job is a play that reaches new people, and the newsletter is where those people go next. I’ve written about building a pipeline beyond referrals if getting new people in the door is where you’re stuck.
It also matters where you are. A newer agency usually runs something like 80% demand and 20% brand, and a newsletter is brand work. The brand-demand split is set by your pipeline rather than your revenue, so a newsletter earns more of your week as the pipeline steadies.
If you’ve already got something sending people your way, hell yeah. Start the list this month, pick your send day, and write it to one buyer. If you haven’t, you haven’t missed anything. Build the feeder first and the newsletter will have somebody to write to when you get there.
Not sure your feeder is strong enough yet? Describe it in the Dynamic Agency Community and ask the owners already running a list what they’d add.
